City Transport Operations Ltd – Licence Revoked After Repeated Tyre and Wheel Security Failures

Last updated: November 17, 2026

Case details

  • Operator: City Transport Operations Ltd (formerly A & A Coach Travel Ltd)
  • Licence: Standard International PSV operator’s licence PB2024186 (granted July 2019; 20 vehicles authorised, 12 in possession)
  • Traffic Area: North East
  • Traffic Commissioner: Anthony Seculer, Deputy Traffic Commissioner
  • Public Inquiry: 15 July 2026; written decision dated 5 August 2026, published 10 September 2026
  • Regulatory outcome: Licence revoked from 15 September 2026. The company and both directors disqualified for 18 months. The Transport Manager lost his repute and was disqualified indefinitely, and must re-take the Transport Manager CPC before acting in that role again.

1. Executive Summary

A North East PSV operator has lost its licence after a Public Inquiry heard evidence of persistent roadworthiness failures stretching back to 2023. Tyres and wheels featured repeatedly: tread worn below the legal limit, a tyre bulging from structural separation, exposed cords on a front tyre and loose wheel nuts, all against a background of missing maintenance records and driver walkaround checks that DVSA found ineffective at every visit.

The operator already had a tyre policy. What it did not have was a working system behind it. The case is a clear reminder that a written policy, without recorded checks, wheel torque procedures and drivers who report what they see, gives no protection to passengers, other road users or the licence itself.

2. Background and Public Inquiry Context

  • The licence was granted in July 2019 for 20 vehicles.
  • A previous Public Inquiry in 2022 cut the authorisation from 20 to 17 vehicles for 11 weeks and issued formal warnings.
  • DVSA maintenance investigations in June 2023, December 2023 and September 2024 were each marked unsatisfactory, with further DVSA reports in August 2025 and June 2026.
  • Over the five years to June 2026 the operator had 51 roadside encounters, resulting in 15 immediate and 7 delayed prohibitions – a mechanical prohibition rate of 43%.
  • In the final year (July 2025 to June 2026) six of eight encounters ended in a mechanical prohibition: a rate of 75%, against a national average of just under 20%.
  • The annual test initial failure rate was 35%, more than four times the national PSV rate of 8.55%.

3. DVSA Findings – Tyres and Wheel Security

Tyre prohibitions

  • April 2023: A coach received an immediate prohibition for a tyre bulging due to separation of its structure, along with a damaged wheel hub.
  • April 2023: Days later, a second vehicle was prohibited for tread worn beyond the legal limit. The operator said the vehicle had not been in use, but ANPR data showed it on the road three days earlier.
  • September 2024: Another immediate, S-marked prohibition for tread worn beyond the legal limit – the S-marking indicating a significant failure in the operator’s maintenance system.
  • December 2025: A prohibition for cords exposed on an offside front tyre. The same vehicle was later stopped by police with expired tax and multiple defects; the operator’s claim that it was a private vehicle was rejected.

Wheel security

  • September 2024: A delayed prohibition for a loose wheel nut.
  • June 2026: An MOT failure for loose wheel nuts on both nearside and offside hubs, with defects classed as “Repair Immediately (major defects)”.
  • DVSA maintenance reports in 2023 and 2024 found no effective wheel security systems or tyre management arrangements.
  • In August 2025, DVSA found the operator now had a tyre policy, but no wheel re-torque procedure or torque records, as required by the DVSA Guide to Maintaining Roadworthiness.
  • Two serious incidents – including a detached hub – were not reported to the Traffic Commissioner as required.

Driver defect reporting

Driver defect reporting was found to be ineffective in every DVSA maintenance investigation from 2023 to 2026. Worn, damaged and structurally failing tyres were being found by DVSA at the roadside rather than by drivers at the start of the day.

Broader maintenance failings

  • Maintenance records were repeatedly late, incomplete or not produced at all; on one occasion the operator said paper records had been destroyed.
  • Safety inspection sheets were incomplete, illegible or not in the operator’s name, and brake tests were carried out after inspections rather than as part of them.
  • Vehicles were used while under prohibition, including one taken for MOT rather than presented for prohibition clearance, and vehicles declared off the road appeared on ANPR records.

4. Traffic Commissioner’s Determination

The Deputy Traffic Commissioner found that the operator’s promises of improvement were not supported by auditable records and, given its history of unfulfilled assurances, could not be trusted. He described the core issue as “one of trust” and concluded that future compliance was highly unlikely. A reduction in vehicle numbers was judged insufficient to reflect the seriousness of the failings, and road safety and fair competition were given priority over the operator’s potential losses.

Outcomes:

  1. The operator lost its good repute and its licence was revoked with effect from 00.00 on 15 September 2026.
  2. The company was disqualified from holding or obtaining an operator’s licence for 18 months.
  3. Both directors were disqualified for 18 months.
  4. The Transport Manager, also a director, lost his repute, was disqualified indefinitely from acting as a transport manager, and must re-take and pass the Transport Manager CPC before acting in the role again.

5. Key Tyre Safety and Compliance Takeaways

  • A tyre policy is only the starting point. It must be backed by recorded tread depths, pressures and condition at every safety inspection, and by records that can be produced on request.
  • Wheel security needs its own procedure. Re-torque wheel nuts after any wheel removal, record it, and use visual indicators or retainers so drivers can spot movement during daily checks.
  • Drivers are the first line of defence. Bulges, exposed cords and worn tread should be found on the walkaround, not at a DVSA roadside check. Train drivers, check their reports and act on them.
  • Replace before the limit. Set an internal replacement threshold above the 1mm legal minimum for PSVs so tyres are changed in planned maintenance, not after a prohibition.
  • Clear prohibitions properly. A prohibited vehicle must not be used until the prohibition is formally cleared – an MOT is not a substitute.
  • Report serious incidents. Wheel and hub failures must be notified to the Traffic Commissioner.
  • Remember ACT: check Air pressure, Condition and Tread on every vehicle, every time.

Source: Traffic Commissioner regulatory decision – City Transport Operations Ltd (formerly A & A Coach Travel Ltd), PB2024186, published on GOV.UK.

Back To Top